New York

North America > 🇺🇸 United States > New York

Should You Hire a Car in New York? This can be broken down into two similar questions - do you need a car in New York (in other words, will your holiday be ruined without one), and is it worth hiring a car in New York - i.e. is a car better value than using public transport? We'll weigh up both questions and give you a response generated by AI, together with our own curated opinion before finally giving a yes or no verdict at the end.
âś… Car Score 7
đźš« No Car Score 10
đźš— Should you rent a car?

(0= absolutely not; 10 = rental car or heavy dependence on taxis absolutely essential)

🗽 New York City: Should You Rent a Car or Not? Here’s the Real Answer

New York is a city that moves — not with cars, but with subways, yellow cabs, ferries, and pure energy. Streets are crowded, parking costs a fortune, and traffic is practically a spectator sport.

🚫 Do NOT rent a car if you’re staying in New York City.
âś… Only consider a car if you are leaving the city to explore upstate New York or surrounding states.

Let’s break it down so you can make the right call on the question of should you rent a car in New York.

🚆 Why You Should Skip the Car in NYC

New York’s public transport system is one of the best in the world — and it’s faster than driving for almost every city journey.

🚇 Benefits of Going Car-Free:

  • The subway runs 24/7 and connects all major attractions

  • Taxis, Uber, and Lyft are everywhere

  • Walking is often faster than driving in central Manhattan

  • Parking garages cost $50–$80 per day

  • Hotels often don’t include parking

  • Tolls and traffic congestion charges add up quickly

➡ In NYC, the car isn’t a convenience — it’s a burden.

🚶 Perfectly Car-Free Activities

You can easily reach everything without a car:

  • Times Square

  • Central Park

  • Broadway theatres

  • 9/11 Memorial & Financial District

  • Statue of Liberty Ferry

  • Brooklyn Bridge & Dumbo

  • Museums (Met, MoMA, Guggenheim)

  • Hudson Yards & The High Line

Just use the subway, walk, or hop in a cab.

đźš— When Renting a Car Makes Sense

A car only becomes useful if you’re leaving the city and exploring outside New York.

✅ Consider a Car If You’re Heading To:

  • Hudson Valley (wine country, hiking, fall foliage)

  • The Hamptons or Montauk (beaches)

  • Niagara Falls (multi-day trip)

  • New England road trip (Boston, Vermont, Maine)

  • Upstate towns like Woodstock, Lake Placid, or the Catskills

➡ Once you exit NYC, driving becomes a pleasure—not a problem.

🧭 Quick Decision Table

Your Trip Style Car Needed?
Manhattan sightseeing ❌ No
Brooklyn, Queens, Bronx exploration ❌ No
Business trip in the city ❌ No
Staying near Times Square or Central Park ❌ No
Upstate NY road trip âś… Yes
Driving to Boston, Hamptons, Niagara âś… Yes

🎯 Final Verdict

  • đźš« Skip the car if you’re staying within the five boroughs. You’ll travel faster by subway and save a lot of money and stress.

  • âś… Rent a car if you’re using New York City as a launchpad for a road trip beyond the city.

🗽 In New York, the real power move isn’t driving — it’s not needing a car at all.

Should You Hire a Car in New York — or Not? Advice on this page has been written using Chat GPT, backed up by 20 years experience in the travel industry. This site is planned for full launch on 1st January 2026. Full terms, advice, FAQs, disclaimer etc to follow. UN flag is a placeholder

.